
The Chatham-Kent Police Service is standing by its officers after a judge ruled that law enforcement breached the rights of a Chatham man who is accused of murdering his daughter.
During a pretrial hearing on Thursday, Superior Court Justice Brian Dube announced that key evidence against 50-year-old David William Thomas was no longer admissible, after ruling that Thomas’ Charter rights had been violated.
Thomas is accused of killing his daughter, 22-year-old Bayli Sellars, whose body was discovered on June 25, 2022, following a fire at 149 Edgar St. in Chatham. Thomas was arrested in British Columbia on a Canada-wide warrant back in May 2024 and charged with first-degree murder, arson with disregard for human life, and indignity to a body.
Following Thursday’s ruling, the Crown asked the judge to dismiss the murder charge, saying there was no reasonable prospect of conviction without the evidence. The other charges have also been stayed.
However, the Crown Attorney’s Office has announced its intention to file an appeal, which will determine whether the evidence will be admissible at trial.
In a statement issued on Friday, CK police officials said the service remains committed to supporting the judicial process as the case proceeds through the legal system.
“We are confident that our officers acted in accordance with their lawful duties and responsibilities,” police said in a statement. “We recognize the ongoing impact these proceedings have on the victim’s family and loved ones. Our thoughts remain with them during this difficult time.”
With the case still before the courts, police said they will not be commenting further on the appeal process.



